Your Mac reports 2 battery health numbers
Updated 6 November 2026 · Who measures this.
Neither is lying: the battery controller publishes 2 capacity figures, and software picks one. When System Settings says 87% and a battery app says 85%, one may be showing the reported figure, a smoothed estimate, and the other the raw figure, the controller's own current measurement, closer to what the pack gives you today. Both move, and macOS's own percentage doesn't always match either.
Which number should you use?
For replacement and warranty questions, use the number macOS shows you: it is the one you can point to on screen. For how much charge you have to spend today, use the raw figure, because that is what the pack is working with right now.
| Your question | Use | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Should I replace the battery? | The number macOS shows, with its Condition line | You can point to it in a warranty conversation |
| How much charge do I have to spend today? | The raw figure | That is what the pack is working with right now |
| Is my battery normal for its mileage? | The number macOS shows | The reports we compare with were read from it |
| Why does my Mac die early? | Neither | That is a question about watts |
The 2 numbers, measured
The controller reports a design capacity (what the pack held when it was new) and then 2 views of what it holds today. On the Mac used for this page:
| What it is | Reading | As a percentage |
|---|---|---|
| Design capacity, when new | 6249 mAh | n/a |
| Reported capacity today: the smoothed figure the controller publishes | 5484 mAh | 87.8% |
| Raw capacity today: the controller's own current measurement | 5332 mAh | 85.3% |
The 2 are 152 mAh apart, about 2.4 percentage points. System Settings showed 87% at that moment.
Why are there 2 battery health numbers?
Because capacity is something the controller estimates, not a fixed quantity you can look up, and the estimate moves with temperature, with how full the pack is and with how recently it was charged. The reported figure is that estimate after smoothing, meant for a label that says "your battery is fine", and it moves too. The raw figure is the estimate as taken.
2 readings 40 minutes apart, while the charge fell from 56% to 32%:
| Reading | Raw | Reported | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| first | 5270 mAh | 5422 mAh | 152 mAh |
| 40 minutes later | 5332 mAh | 5484 mAh | 152 mAh |
Both moved by the same 62 mAh (about a percentage point), and across that pair the gap did not change by a hundredth. 3 readings 20 seconds apart did not move at all.
The gap itself is not fixed, though. On another day the same Mac read 5138 mAh raw against 5446 mAh reported, a gap of 308 mAh. Later that day the raw figure had not shifted by a single milliamp-hour, while the reported one had fallen to 5290, closing the gap to 152. The Mac was plugged in and near full on both readings, which is a fair explanation for the reported figure moving. Expect a gap of a couple of points; don't expect a constant.
What does WattMate show?
Neither of the 2. It reads the raw figure and then refuses to let health climb: as long as the cycle count says the pack was not replaced, the figure is never allowed above last month's recorded one. On the Mac above that means 84%, from an earlier month's reading. A health figure that walks back up is measurement noise, not a battery growing younger, and we would rather look pessimistic than print noise.
Because that means disagreeing with System Settings, the app says so on the same screen: it prints the controller's figure next to its own and says the number in System Settings "can differ from both". On macOS 27 it says instead that System Settings "may show a higher figure".
The energy side of the app (watts, watt-hours, minutes) is counted separately, and where it needs the pack's full charge it uses the reported figure,
NominalChargeCapacity, as the page on percentage jumps says.
Can either number explain short battery life?
No. A gap of 2 or 3 points between them is normal: 4 Macs read 2.4 to 2.8 points. A gap between health and how long the Mac actually lasts is a different problem with a different cause: a battery at 90% can still give you 3 hours if something is holding the machine awake or drawing hard in the background. Battery health says 96% but it only lasts 4 hours takes that one apart.
Questions people ask
Which app is telling the truth?
Both, if they say which number they are showing. The failure isn't picking one key over the other. It is printing a percentage with no statement of what it is a percentage of.
Why does the number change during the day?
Because it is an estimate that moves with charge level and temperature. On the Mac measured here it moved a full percentage point in 40 minutes. An app that shows the raw figure without smoothing will show that wandering; one that never lets the number climb above last month's (as WattMate does) will hide the rebounds above that level.
Is a 2-point gap a sign of a failing battery?
No. Both figures came from the same healthy pack, reported by macOS as being in Normal condition, on the same second.
Should I worry when it drops below 80%?
Apple designs the pack to retain up to 80% of its original capacity at its rated cycle count: a design target, not a failure threshold. A battery below it works; it just holds less.
How it was measured
| The Mac on this page | One MacBook Pro 14-inch (Mac15,10, M3 Max, macOS 26.5.2), at 533 cycles, and at 538 on the day of the 308 mAh gap. Every figure above comes from it, except the 4-Mac comparison. |
| Other Macs | 4 of our test Macs on macOS 14.2.1 to 27.2: the 2 figures read 2.4 to 2.8 points apart. |
| What macOS printed | In the same minute it matched the reported figure on 2 of those Macs, the raw one on 1 and neither on 1: the health checker has the table. On the Mac above, at 578 cycles on macOS 27.0, it said 87%, while the reported figure was 84.0% and the raw one 81.6%. |
What this doesn't show
- Your own gap. The 152 mAh is a property of that pack and that moment. Yours will be a different size, and it can be smaller or larger. The mechanism applies: there are 2 published capacity numbers, they differ, and software picks one.
- How macOS picks its number. We have not found it.
Related: health is fine but the Mac dies early · how we count everything else · why charging says "on hold" · why the percentage jumps · health against cycle count
See both numbers, and what they cost you
10 days free, no card · Requires macOS 14 or later · Apple silicon