macOS says an app is "Using Significant Energy"
Updated 11 November 2026 · Who measures this.
The battery menu names the app, and that is the entire message. It doesn't say how much energy or since when, and the threshold is not published. By the time you open Activity Monitor to check, the busy stretch may already be over.
What should you do when the menu names an app?
Check whether it is still busy. Click the battery icon in the menu bar, where the apps are listed under the heading Using Significant Energy. Then open Activity Monitor → Energy and sort by Energy Impact.
| What you see | What it means | What to do |
|---|---|---|
| The named app is at the top | You have your answer while it's still true | Quitting it is a reasonable move |
| The named app is near the bottom | You may have arrived after the fact | Don't conclude the Mac was wrong. Look at the 12 hr Power column |
| The same app is named every day | It gets busy repeatedly, which doesn't say what the total costs you | Compare it in watts: what each app costs |
12 hr Power is the app's average Energy Impact over the last 12 hours, or since the Mac started. A high figure says the app was busy at some point, but not when, for how long, or in watts. Energy Impact itself is a relative number without a unit: it ranks apps, it doesn't give watts.
What does the menu tell you, and what does it withhold?
| What you get | What it amounts to |
|---|---|
| The name of an app | The one thing macOS commits to. It's a pointer, and a useful one |
| A number (watts, percent, anything) | Never shown. Activity Monitor's Energy Impact column carries no unit either |
| A timestamp | None. The menu doesn't say when the app earned its place on the list |
| The threshold that put it there | Not published, and not something we have measured |
| Whether it's still happening | Unknown to us. We have never recorded what that menu said |
What is the threshold for "significant energy"?
We don't know. Apple publishes no figure, so there is nothing to quote, and we have no measurement of our own: WattMate estimates watts per app but does not watch the contents of the system menu, so we have no pairing between "this app was drawing X watts" and "this app appeared in the list".
The run that would narrow it down is simple: record what the battery menu lists, on a fixed interval, alongside the per-app watts on the same Mac. We have not done that, and we have not seen anyone show that they have.
Why does Activity Monitor disagree with the menu?
Possibly because the 2 displays describe different moments; Apple doesn't say whether they count the same thing either. That is our best explanation, not a finding, because we never recorded what the menu said. What we did measure is how fast the whole Mac's draw moves: on one MacBook Pro, measured in windows of a minute or two, in 1 window in 10 it fell by 8.00 W or more from the window before.
| Change from one window to the next | Measured |
|---|---|
| Median of signed changes | +0.11 W: rises are about as common as falls |
| 1 window in 10 fell by | 8.00 W or more |
| 1 window in 10 rose by at least | +7.32 W |
| 5 largest drops between neighbouring windows | −27.1 · −25.1 · −22.7 · −19.6 · −17.5 W |
Drops that large are rare, but heavy windows were not:
| Of the 436 windows on that MacBook Pro | Count |
|---|---|
| 30 W and above | 136 (31.2%) |
| 40 W and above | 35 (8.0%) |
| 50 W and above | 10 (2.3%) |
So the menu naming an app that then sits near the bottom of Activity Monitor is possible on a Mac whose whole draw can fall by 20 W or more from one window to the next. If that is what happened, neither display is lying: they describe different moments.
The catch: you have to be measuring before you look
Every tool above waits for you to open it, and none keeps a timeline per app. A burst that has already ended leaves at most a 12-hour average without a unit. WattMate estimates every app's watts, window after window, so when the menu names something, what it was doing and what it cost are already recorded, along with what quitting it is worth in minutes on your Mac.
Questions people ask
The menu names an app, but Activity Monitor shows it near the bottom. Which one is wrong?
Most likely neither. On the Mac we measured, the 5 largest drops between neighbouring windows were 27.1, 25.1, 22.7, 19.6 and 17.5 W. A burst that has already ended looks harmless in a live display.
Should I quit the app it names?
If it's still at the top of Activity Monitor's Energy list, that's a reasonable move. In general, though, quitting apps buys less than people expect: does quitting apps actually save battery?
It names the same app every day. Is that app the problem?
Not by itself. Being named repeatedly may mean it gets busy repeatedly. For 6 common apps, we have estimates from our own Macs: Chrome, Xcode, Claude, Telegram, Slack and Spotify. Some of them cost far less than their reputation suggests.
Does the warning mean something is wrong with my Mac?
A place on that list does not by itself indicate a fault. It reports activity. It becomes worth acting on when your battery is going somewhere you didn't intend.
How it was measured
| Watt figures | 436 windows of a minute or two on battery, about 11 hours, on one 14-inch MacBook Pro (Mac15,10, M3 Max, 36 GB, macOS 26.5.2) under a developer's load. The change table is 435 consecutive pairs of those windows. |
| The menu | Never recorded. Everything said about it comes from what it shows on screen. |
What this doesn't show
- The macOS threshold. These numbers describe how fast a Mac's draw moves, not how macOS decides what to list.
- That any of those drops was the app the menu named. We never recorded the menu, so that link is unmeasured.
- Other Macs. A different Mac, or the same Mac used differently, would show different steps. Take both the shape and the figures as one example.
- Bursts shorter than a window. They add their energy to the window, but we can't see when inside it they happened or how long they lasted.
Related: what each app costs · what Chrome costs, measured on 2 Macs · does quitting apps actually save battery?
Have the answer before you go looking
10 days free, no card · Requires macOS 14 or later · Apple silicon